Wednesday, January 11, 2012

Peter Schreuder, Hydrologist, Hired

July 27, 2011

Dear Alliance Members and Friends:

I am please to be able to tell you that the Keystone Heights City Council approved the hiring of Mr. Peter Schreuder, Hydrologist and Author of the well known Schreuder Report to represent the City at the upcoming Stakeholder meetings that will be held by the SJRWMD to implement strategies to help recover the lakes in our area. 

This was a very tough decision for the Council because of the meager City budget.  Though each of the Council Members love the lakes just as much as the rest of us they cannot commit to more money than is in the coffers.   

Members of the Save Our Lakes Organization, Lake Area Water Alliance, Santa Fe Lake Dwellers, Garden Club of the Lakes, KH Woman’s Club, Melrose Business & Community Association, Keystone Business Association and other members of the community were all there to support the hiring of Mr. Schroeder as this is the best and possibly last shot our community has to actually do something to rehabilitate our lakes and hopefully restore the aquifer.  Since the City does not have engineers and hydrologists on its staff as does the large cities like Jacksonville and other big water consumers, Mr. Schroeder’s expertise will be invaluable as the technical advisor to the lake area citizenry.  We are very fortunate he has already invested a lot of his time for free helping us get this far.

The Council took this bold step with the reassurances from those attending that the community would step up and help shoulder the expenses necessary to retain Mr. Schreuder.  There is only enough money in the City budget for the initial work that will need to be done to complete a project of this scope.  Mayor Hildreth has been working on getting some matching funds from the County to help out but this will still not be enough.  However, we as a community whether we live inside or outside the City borders, this is our community and we are going to have to help the City with this expense as we are also Stakeholders that need to be represented at the Stakeholder table by Mr. Schreuder.

In the near future, you will be called upon to help with a fundraiser to raise a war chest for this fight to save our lakes and I hope you will respond wholeheartedly.  It is only together in partnership with the City, County, our organizations and individual contributions that we will be able to do what needs to be done to succeed in restoring our lakes so that we can recharge the economy in our community and most of all protect our water resources for future generations.

I would like to  have an Alliance Meeting on Wednesday, August 24th,  7:00PM at the KH Womans Club to discuss our progress at the Stakeholder meeting on the 11th, future plans for fundraising, etc .  As always we are looking for new  members so don’t hesitate to invite a new organization to join us.  Please let me know if you can come or not so I can change the date if necessary.   

 Looking forward to your reply,  Jackie

Stakeholder Review Draft: Groundwater Model Development Project

The following is an email exchange between Jackie Host, President of LAWA, and Alfred Canepa, Associate Director, Department of Resource Management at the St Johns River Water Management District, on July 25-26, 2011:

Greetings Al,

In reviewing the draft for the collaborative effort on the regional groundwater model development project I noticed that the third party Stakeholder was “other parties yet to be identified”.  I have received a flurry of communications regarding this from members of the community as one cannot help but notice all of the stakeholders that are identified are utility, agriculture and phosphate companies.  I am very hopeful that you are considering some other participants such as University of Florida or USGA professionals to balance your working group. 

If I understood Jennifer correctly, this is a technical working group for the groundwater model and will have no direct bearing or will slow up any progress on the Stakeholder group she is putting together for the Brooklyn, Cowpen, Geneva recovery strategy. 

Your thoughts on the above would be appreciated so I could report it to my Alliance members.

Sincerely,
Jackie Host



Jackie –

The charter you are referring to is for a project to develop a new regional groundwater model for parts of north central Florida, north east Florida and south Georgia.  This is a separate effort from the Prevention/Recovery strategy effort currently underway. 

The stakeholder groups you see listed so far are those who became aware of the project before it was posted on our web site and have expressed interest in participating.  The purpose of posting the charter on the web site is to inform a wider variety of stakeholders of the project and to solicit their involvement should they so desire.

There are three levels of involvement possible for stakeholders: Project Team (any stakeholder interested in the chartering and progress of this project), Steering Team (interested and qualified stakeholders who will provide high-level direction to the Technical Team) and Technical Team (stakeholders with technical expertise in groundwater modeling, hydrogeology, hydrology or related fields).  More detail on the teams is provided in the Definitions section of the draft project charter.

Once the model is developed, we will likely have it peer reviewed by one or two groundwater modeling technical experts not involved in the project.

This new model will not be used to develop the Prevention/Recovery strategies, as model development is expected to be a multi-year effort.  The current version of the District’s Northeast Florida groundwater model (Version 4, NEF) will be used to develop strategies.  Accordingly, development of the new model will not slow down the Prevention/Recovery strategy effort.

Alfred P. Canepa

JEA buys former Coggin Pontiac property for water main project

July 19, 2011, Florida Times Union

JEA has purchased land formerly occupied by Coggin Pontiac at Southside and Atlantic Boulevards for a $40 million project involving running a new water main from downtown to the Southside.

Full article

Defanging the EPA

Excerpt from an email from Marion Hilliard, Chairman of Environmental Concerns/Legislation Committee for the National Garden Clubs, Inc. on July 11, 2011:

Without public hearings HR 2018, the Clean Water Cooperative Federalism Act of 2011 was approved by the U.S. House Transportation & Infrastructure Committee on June 22, 2011 by a vote of 35-19.  This was the boldest bi-partisan attempt we have seen in years to dismantle the Clean Water Act of 1972.

If this bill passes and become law it would take us back to the times when there was a patchwork quilt of laws and standards - when states made decisions on dumping untreated sewage or toxic chemicals into rivers and streams that traveled through neighboring states.

Please know that this bill would:
- Overturn almost 40 years of Federal legislation by preventing EPA from protecting public health and water quality;
-  Prevent EPA from providing its views on whether a proposed project that pollutes or even destroys lakes, streams or wetlands would violate CWA standards;
-  Remove EPA's existing state coordination role and eliminate the careful Federal/State balance established in the current CWA;
-  Prevent EPA from protecting communities from unacceptable adverse impacts to the water supplies and the environment caused by Federal permits;
-  Substantively eliminate the opportunity for EPA, the federal government's expert of water quality, to comment on Federal permits impacting water quality and public health;
and would limit the EPA Administrator's capabilities as outlined in the Technical Analysis of H.R. 2018.  

Marion's Verbal Comments:
The proposed bill H.R. 2018 is part of a tsunami wave of anti-environmental bills and riders being pushed on Capitol Hill and across states to weaken laws that keep our drinking water and waterways clean and safe.  Our health depends on a strong CWA.  Is it realistic that we should turn back the clock to times of dirtier rivers, lakes. streams and coastal areas?  Are we asking for a return of environmental disasters similar to New York's "Love Canal" and Pennsylvania's "on-fire river" ?   
 
Marion Hilliard
Chairman
Environmental Concerns/Legislation Committee 
National Garden Clubs, Inc.

Status of H.R. 2018 - PASSED the House and is in the Senate for debate.

Proposed GP Pipeline to Dump into St Johns River

The following is an exerpt from a Riverkeeper email on July 7, 2011:

St. Johns Riverkeeper is hosting a public forum regarding the proposed pipeline by Georgia-Pacific to divert its polluted wastewater into the St. Johns River.

This is your chance to learn more about this issue, ask questions, and find out what you can do.  I will provide a presentation about the proposed pipeline and our concerns.  We will be joined by Dr. Bob Hayes, a chemical engineer, hired by St. Johns Riverkeeper to do a peer review of the GP study that has been used to justify the pipeline. 

What:    Georgia-Pacific Pipeline Public Forum
When:    Thursday, July 14  6:30 - 8:00 pm
Where:  Wyndham Jacksonville Riverfront Hotel
               1515 Prudential Dr., Jacksonville 32207

As we reported in our last e-mail update, we are still working with the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) staff to get answers to important questions regarding the sources of pollution at the Georgia-Pacific (GP) paper mill in Palatka.  Until the sources of GP's pollution are identified and fully understood, it is not feasible to identify the best solution(s) to fix the problems, and that includes the pipeline. 

We based our questions on the reports of two experts - Dr. Bob Hayes, hired to do the peer review, and the other a highly-regarded chemist, Dr. Lucinda Sonnenberg, hired by DEP to provide technical expertise needed to help them evaluate the GP permit. 

Hayes found significant technical errors in the GP study and recommends a comprehensive chemical engineering study of the mill and its entire waste stream.  He uses a MRI analogy, suggesting that a doctor often needs an MRI to know what is going on inside the body to better understand the source of the ailment before prescribing a treatment. 

Hayes has over 50 years of experience in the pulp and paper industry, and has identified and worked on numerous mills that have solved their wastewater pollution problems with a variety of alternative strategies.   So, we know there are alternatives that have worked and could work for GP.  However, until the "MRI" is done, it is not feasible to select the best option for GP.   

Dr. Hayes and Dr. Sonnenberg both independently came to the same conclusion.  They both concur that more information is needed to thoroughly understand and pinpoint the sources of GP's pollution problems and to sufficiently identify and evaluate all of the alternatives to the pipeline that may exist.  

In the meantime, please make sure that you have signed the petition to Governor Scott and Secretary Vinyard opposing the Georgia-Pacific pipeline at www.ClearnerGP.com.  Better yet, make a phone call or send a personal letter or e-mail.  You can find contact information on the Cleaner GP website. Also, consider sending a letter to the editor of your local newspaper. 

You can learn more about this and other issues by frequently visiting the St.Johns Riverkeeper website and by becoming a Facebook fan.  Please, stay informed and  remain involved. 

With your help, we are confident that a solution can be found that resolves GP's pollution problems and keeps jobs in Palatka, without the need for a pipeline.
 
We hope to see you at the forum next Thursday, July 14th.

For the River,
Your St. Johns Riverkeeper

Technical Support from a Hydrologist

In July, the City of Keystone Heights in conjunction with LAWA (and other groups) sought the hiring of a hydrologist to provide technical support for our water cause. A representative from the SJRWMD helped to clarify what that support might entail:

Here are some thoughts regarding the type of technical support that you may want to seek from Peter or another qualified consultant. This reflects the type of technical support that I envision stakeholders providing through the process. Please be aware that 1) this is not a formal recommendation, and 2) even with a revised scope that is limited to these type of technical tasks, the decision would likely remain the same regarding the current lack of District cost-share funds.   
 
Identify Proposed Measures
  • Possible measures (i.e. projects) that may improve lake levels;
  • When developing the measures, be mindful of feasibility, assumptions, and outside factors that would need to be addressed in order for the proposed measure(s) to be implemented;
  • Work with the Development Team to determine what level of detail is necessary; and
  • Develop a written report that the client could bring forward to the Development Team.
Review SJRWMD Analysis of the Benefits of Proposed Measures
  • Provide a peer review of technical analyses that quantified the benefits of the proposed measure(s); and
  • Interpret findings for the client.

Ocala Taps Floridan Aquifer

Beware of easy remedies: "Ocala gets approval for money saving water supply".

The city will be allowed to draw water from the lower Floridan aquifer instead of two costly alternatives: extracting from a distant source like the Ocklawaha River, or building a desalination plant for $500 Million. But what will it cost to suck the Floridan aquifer dry?

Aticle from Ocala.com, June 30, 2011.